Will the federal authorities ever repair the Citizenship Act?…

Unconstitutional laws stopping misplaced Canadians from gaining citizenship stays on the books.

On April 22, 2025, the Ontario Superior Courtroom of Justice prolonged the deadline to Nov 20, 2025 for the federal authorities to amend the Citizenship Act’s first era restrict (FGL) to citizenship by descent.

Schedule a Free Canadian Citizenship Session with the Cohen Immigration
Legislation Agency

In her revealed resolution Decide Jasmine Akbarali famous that she additional prolonged the deadline maugre “the continuing hardship to these whose constitutional rights continued to be breached by the boundaries on by-product citizenship.”

The FGL prevents youngsters of residents by descent from gaining Canadian citizenship by descent.

Below citizenship by descent, youngsters of Canadian residents acquire citizenship at start, even when born outdoors Canada.

In 2009, the federal authorities restricted citizenship by descent, including provisions to the Citizenship Act collectively known as the first-generation restrict (FGL).

Below the present Citizenship Act, youngsters born overseas inherit Canadian citizenship if born to a minimum of one guardian who was themself born in Canada or naturalized.

But when their solely Canadian guardian(s) gained citizenship by descent, their baby born overseas doesn’t inherit Canadian citizenship by descent—therefore the ‘first era restrict.’

The present type of the FGL was dominated unconstitutional by the Ontario Superior Courtroom of Justice in December of 2023 for infringing on rights enshrined within the Canadian Constitution of Rights and Freedoms.

At the moment, the Courtroom gave the federal authorities six months’ time to amend the laws.

The Crown selected to not attraction the ruling, and launched Invoice C-71 in Could of 2024. Invoice C-71 proposed a repair by offering an exception to the FGL in circumstances the place the Canadian guardian met a “substantial connection” check, outlined as having lived in Canada for a minimum of three years previous to the start or adoption of the kid.

Invoice C-71 by no means turned legislation, and the Courtroom prolonged the deadline on 4 events previous to this one — most not too long ago to April 25, 2025.

When Parliament was prorogued on January 6, 2025, Invoice C-71 died.

Within the meantime, the federal authorities launched interim measures on March 13, 2025, permitting these affected by the FGL to use for discretionary grants of citizenship.

At the moment, the federal authorities additionally requested that the Courtroom prolong the deadline for an additional 12 months, to March 20, 2026.

To amend the Citizenship Act, the federal authorities might want to introduce a brand new invoice after Parliament reconvenes following the final election on April 28.

The choice on Tuesday has supplied the federal authorities with eight months’ time.

In her revealed resolution, Akbarali wrote that “the occasion that varieties authorities ought to have the ability to cross remedial laws inside this timeframe if it chooses to make that laws a precedence.”

If the federal government misses the deadline and the Courtroom chooses to not prolong it additional, the Courtroom could strike down or learn down the offending parts of the laws, rendering them inoperative.

Akbarali made the choice out of concern “that the pursuits of the general public will probably be negatively affected if the declaration of invalidity comes into drive with out alternative laws in place, particularly given the complexity of citizenship laws.”

She additionally famous that “Rights-holders shouldn’t be made to undergo the impacts of an unconstitutional legislation indefinitely” and that “the general public is entitled to anticipate Parliament to fulfil its legislative position and cross laws.”

Schedule a Free Canadian Citizenship Session with the Cohen Immigration
Legislation Agency